I'm constantly presented with the question of which is better for your garden: mulch or stone? So, I thought I'd put together a list of the pros and cons for both so that you can decide which would be best for you.
* Both retain moisture in the soil
* Both help keep a cool temperature for your plants
* Both help reduce weeds when installed properly - each should be installed at a depth of at least 3" to be effective
* Both are safe for pets and children
Although my neighbors were concerned when I first had a pile of mulch delivered on my driveway - worried I would attract termites to the neighborhood - the only way termites would be a problem is if I didn't get my mulch from a reputable distributor and termites already existed in the mulch. While mulch does attract beneficial insects and pollinators to your plants, it will only cause harm if your supplier is infected. Carefully choosing a reputable landscape supplier is important. Mulch does also attract some fungus that will not necessarily harm your plants, but will be unattractive to your landscape. A fire could also present a problem as mulch can be flammable.
The benefit of mulch is that it breaks down over time providing your plants with nutrients that will help them grow and make a more attractive garden.
Stone is a much lower maintenance and comes in a large variety of colors. It does not need to be replaced as often as mulch, and it is a more permanent solution. The color and type of stone chosen can be an attractive addition to your landscape. Stone is also fire resistant and stays in place during wind and rain. When there is no compaction, water will flow freely through the stone to your plants' roots.
So, basically it comes down to preference ... which look do you prefer?
Michelle Iskowitz
1:39 pm on Thursday, July 21, 2011
This is has been a bone of contention between my husband and I for years. He feels stone is more effective at eliminating weeds, less expensive and easier maintenance than mulch. Not only do I love to garden but I like the natural look of mulch more than that of stone. I also like the fact that mulch adds nutrients to the soil. So far, I've dug my heels into the ground (or mulch) and it's worked.
JOSETTE COOK
9:37 am on Friday, July 22, 2011
I'm a huge fan of mulch, as well, and was very surprised to find little difference in benefits between the two. Stand your ground -- it's better for the plants -- and thanks for sharing! :)